I have already read Georges posts and he makes some excellent points as always.
I have never known George indulge in personal attacks.
Gervase, you would do well to take a leaf out of his book.

why should I drink a cup of tea? I hate the stuff.
I find that remark patronising.
Jeremy RS quote.
This is a bizarre thread, made worse by Dick's refusal (inability) to name names, other than those whom he personally dislikes, or give examples.
I havent named any names of bad reviewers[so whats this rubbish about ones he personally dislikes].
I am afraid [imo] yor post is not convincing.
why should I trust you[who are you, God?.]
I disagree with the rest of your post,so lets leave it at that.
I think it is a case of professionalism is expected of musicans,but any uncle tom cobbley amateur,can be allowed to do a review.
standards need to be improved [imo],peoples livelihoods can be affected by any literate but musically ignorant reviewer.