The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #123141   Message #2713159
Posted By: The Sandman
31-Aug-09 - 04:02 PM
Thread Name: music critics,do we need them?
Subject: RE: music critics,do we need them?
John P,I did not say like Musical traditions,I do like it, 99 percent of its reviews are very good.
however I made a mistake it is not a professional magazine,as far as I know ,the Editor and the reviewers are not paid,it purports to have a professional standard,and generally speaking is professional in its outlook.
no,I have been ordered by Joe Offer,to neither publish the review on this forum or name it.
John P,
I am not in charge of this forum ,neither am I in charge of what is permissible to be printed on this forum,this forum has an adminstrator he is called Joe Offer,I abide by his wishes.
finally, John,I am entitled to an opinion,which all was my previous post was,I am not preventing anything from being published,I am entitled to have an opinion as to whether the Editor should have published it.
you seem to be telling me what to do,[quote]
[Censorship, GSS? If you don't like a publication, stop reading it. If you like the publication, but just didn't like the one review, tell the editor about it an move on.[end of quote]
and yet at the same time accusing me of trying to have authority over other peoples opinions.