To all the people who have contributed to this thread.

I doubt more correspondence will take us much further. I feel that my own, (many teachers would think) very liberal position has been stated. In case you don't get it Lizzie - I am in favour.

My argument against home education (UK) is that anyone - but anyone - is allowed to do it, with no proof of competence and knowledge.

And in that context Lizzie you are a shining beacon.