The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #124927 Message #2763081
Posted By: Steve Gardham
09-Nov-09 - 06:26 PM
Thread Name: Why does the song end like this?-Young Billy Brown
Subject: RE: Why does the song end like this?
What's the problem with the 6 months? She hadn't actually had the child by then, was only pregnant, in broadside versions anyway. In one version 'Valentines morn' c1840 the appropriate verse runs When three long months were gone and past, This young sailor he came riding by, She said, young man I am with child by you, And the same thing you can't deny.
The last verse of this version runs
When seven long years were gone and past This sailor return'd with his hands full of gold, She never blam'd him for his long absence, Nor his courage for being so bold.
I don't see any problem with any of this song. As others have stated it is of its time, very typical in its outlook to fidelity and children out of wedlock. Sailors had 'wives' in every port and birth control was unheard of among the lower classes. The sailors and their 'wives' were well aware of the high mortality rate among sailors in the late 18thc early 19thc. They took their pleasures where and when they could.