I think one of the things that concerns me is the way X-factor constantly emphasises how much the contestants want to succeed, as if this was the main thing that would ensure their success. They're always heard saying that they've been dreaming of nothing else but a singing career since they were two years old, and it means the world to them - absolutely everything! - to win, and how ghastly and unthinkable it would be if they had to go back to their old job, etc etc.

Even the winners are often heard exhorting others to "Just follow the dream!" as if you could become a successful singer by sheer willpower. They never say, "Take some singing lessons. Get some experience singing in pubs and clubs. Find a style of singing that suits you. Ask other people for critical feedback" ...etc. But no, it's just presented as a matter of wanting it badly enough and then it'll happen.

And I'd love to hear a contestant be brave enough to say, "Well it's only a competition and a bit of fun. It means quite a lot to me but it's not my whole world. I might as well have a go, and if I don't succeed, well, what have I lost?"

And for what it's worth, not all the previous winners have seen much in the way of success. Some have vanished without trace. Leona Lewis is the exception rather than the rule.

Marje