The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #46361   Message #2806840
Posted By: Joe Offer
08-Jan-10 - 02:51 PM
Thread Name: Origins: Oleanna (Ditmar Meidel, Norway, 1853)
Subject: DT Correction: Oleanna
Hi, Paul -
I moved you over here. Here's what's in the Digital Tradition. Let's see what people think about whether a corrected version should be placed in the Digital Tradition (DT). In the case of a "folk" song, there often is no "correct" version (but we do have a number of songs in the DT that are just plain wrong, traditional or not).
Here's the DT version:
Here is a Pete Seeger version, just a bit different from what I posted above:
Do you think this second version is a good replacement for what's in the DT? This is the version most people sing. I propose that for accuracy, we should add a second version from Norwegian Emigrant Songs and Ballads.
-Joe-