Bill: I did respond. I agreed with you. I said "So if you average Jan Feb and MAR and compare them to and average going back to 1963 you are right. The last three winters have been warmer than average."

Still the NOAA chart shows no global warming for the lower 48 for 110 years, None, zero, nada, zip, zilch. 0. The purple long term mean line is flat.

You can talk about Arizona, Pocatello and crime rates all you want but where is the global warming in that chart?