When I first clicked on this video I didn't think I'd like this version, but I found it extremely compelling. I could do without the "rap" section that is mixed in and in my opinion is totally unnecessary, but I think Jim Moray really captured the tragedy of this awful (awful in a good sense, as in dramatic and emotional) ballad. I'm not usually a fan of modernized renditions of ballads, but this one really haunted me and I listened to it several times.

Jim Moray singing "Lucy Wan"