There is something in the human personality that can't stand an unsolved mystery. I'm quite comfortable saying "I don't know why that happened,"Jeri wrote in a post above, short and to the point.
In three words: Accepting the unexplained,
however, not Accepting the unexplainable. I can find no fault with the first formulation.'Unexplainable' rules out that there might be an explanation well known but not to you; that there is an explanation which is not known yet, but will be entirely scientific if it's known; that there is a completely down to earth explanation which may never be found;(and many more)...what you have in mind is only one single of several possibilities.
Go on, but you'll have to stand analytical comment.
Wolfgang