The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #129840   Message #2925468
Posted By: CarolC
11-Jun-10 - 12:07 PM
Thread Name: BS: New Israeli atrocity: attack on Gaza aid
Subject: RE: BS: New Israeli atrocity: attack on Gaza aid
I had noticed the laser light, too, but I forgot to mention it. As Lox said, it's an important part of the evidence.


The blood scene is compelling Lox. Carol previously thought it might be paint.

In the lower quality video, I wasn't able to see the amount of it. I thought it was just a little bit of paint splattered on the wall. But after seeing the higher quality video, I can see that it's not spattered at all, and there's far more of it than would be the case if it was from paint pellets. There's a lot of it and it's dripping down from the open hatch.


Carol, I have only argued from the video evidence.

Except that you have not. As someone else pointed out, you are arguing from what is not in the video evidence rather than what is in the video evidence. And since you aren't in a position to know what you can't see or hear, you can't use that as evidence. But we do have the witness testimonies and so far all of the evidence that has turned up has corroborated their testimonies and discredited the Israeli version of events. On that basis, and because the passengers are calling for the release of all of the footage and still shots, we can make a reasonable judgment that the passengers are telling the truth, and the Israeli government is lying.