That is good Murray. I have never heard that version. I like it alot thanks. It seems like people used to switch to the major chord for a while around here with it. I am not sure when or why it all started bc when I was a kid I remember it holding the minor chord all the way through. Then the major came into play a few yrs ago but now everyone is back to the way I remember it as a kid. Of course I am talking about the way they play around here in West Kentucky. I have listened to versions played every way you can imagine of it. Funny how things like that occur. Just out of nowhere it seems they will take a trad song make it different then revert back to the trad way for the area.