"All Is Well" is also in these books:

John Boyden, The Eastern Harp (1848), p. 122

Revival Melodies, or, Songs of Zion (1842), p. 18

The Jubilee Harp (1868), p. 230

Eben Tourjee, The Tribute of Praise and Methodist Protestant Hymn Book (1882), p. 265

Thomas Whittemore, Conference Hymns and Tunes: First and Second Books (1843), 1st bk, p. 16

John Winebrenner, The Seraphina, or, Christian Library of Church Music (1862), p. 396