I know I will probably be hated and shunned forever for this, but I always liked "Scarlet Ribbons" even though it was listed as one of the songs that a significant number of Mudcatters seem to think of as distasteful. I don't know what attracts me to it, maybe it's the melody- but I always saw the ribbons as an anonymous gift. Maybe the father doesn't know where the ribbons came from because his wife or whoever didn't want anyone to know she was getting the daughter a surprise. And maybe no-one knew because the girl knew her father mightn't be able to find them. Does anyone else have songs that are "guilty pleasures' that they like even though others on the forum don't?