I agree with one thing, Alan - Anyone who advocates such punishment is indeed an areshole. But what I disagree with is that there is nothing ironic about the song - I have already stated my reasons. I also don't believe that such songs belong in museums but would it not be better if you didn't use the thread to push your already well known views further? How about you start another thread about where old songs belong? Or I will if you like! We can disagree as much as we like without spoiling someone else's thread:-)

Cheers

dave