The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #138735 Message #3187584
Posted By: Big Al Whittle
14-Jul-11 - 01:52 PM
Thread Name: Do purists really exist?
Subject: RE: Do purists really exist?
What the hell - it was a long time ago.
The point was, you couldn't trust a traddie with a three song spot - not to demolish your audience to a place where they would never return.
I went tofolkclubs from the 60's . then i got married in 71 and I started taking my in laws round to folk clubs. An ordinary guy who'd worked as a miner and in the hosiery factories of the midlands plus his wife. Just guys who could entertain them - Murf, Brimstone, Lockran, pete Quinn, Jasper, Alex Campbell, ian Campbell's group.
They went explorong on their own and encountered Bellamy and Carthy, Bob Davernport and never darkened the door of a folk club again.
That's okay. these guys were challenging and confrontational in their style of presenting folk music.
But without a significant interface with humankind - whatever the 1954 committee says - in my book, it ain't folkmusic.
Now that makes me a purist of one sort. There are purists of the other sort - who say what is writ large on the temple wall is folkmusic, because it is - lots of terrific reasons. None of them good enough for me. But they satisfy some folk.