The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #140399   Message #3230096
Posted By: Jim Carroll
27-Sep-11 - 03:27 PM
Thread Name: BS: Palestine
Subject: RE: BS: Palestine
"I said that their failure to stop it shamed them."
Because the evidence exposed the fact that not only were the killers driven to the site by the Israelis and given illumination in order to carry out the massacre - no "failure" but total complicity   
I didn't comment on your making it a "thirty year old" massacre - do we have a moratorium on Massacres - and shouldn't someone have told Simon Wiesenthal.
You really do scrape the bottom of the barrel to defend atrocities
"there was no evidence to support some of the claims. "
and yet there was enough for the Israeli enquiry to find themselves half-guilty and even name names, but they did manage to boot the guilty party upstairs before he had to face the consequences of his guilt.
You have the facts on the matter and you have the "expert" judgement that made up the enquiry (or aren't they "expert" enough for you?
"You deleted the acknowledgement"
I deleted nothing - I took the reference to the Israeli role in the massacre as a block and carefully pointed out that this was what I had done, giving your past behaviour as a reason for my doing so - a little different from erasing whole sentences to turn the article on its head - as you have done.
"That mistake was made many years ago and has never been repeated."
Then you'll be able to show us where it was retracted or disproved - won't you?
White phosphorus was used as an anti-personell weapon in both Fallujah and Gaza and you wand two-gun Terri have had this pointed out to you on numerous occasions - though characteristically you both choose to ignore it.
Mike,
I am in no way suggesting that Israeli behaviour was as serious as the holocaust - I would be as agenda-driven as Keith were I to do so.
I am suggesting that the mindsets that fueled both came out of the same stable - race murded is race murder as far as I'm concerned
Incidentally - someone here has been kind enough to point out that I have acquired a fake facebook entry - I'm pretty sure I know who did it and I'm inclined to leave it where it is - I was never one for medals and prizes, but I tend to treasure this one as an example of a sewer-rat trying to bite back.
Jim Carroll