I sent Alasdair Robert's contact address (fromhis web site) and email I'll reproduce the entire email exchange unedited [except as indicated in brackets].

I think the best you can say, from my perspective, is that Alasdair just doesn't get it. I could say something even less complementary. But as he doesn't seem to think it worth reading a thread commenting on his music, he won't see that comment!

Me:
If Alasdair hasn't seen this thread, he may find it of interest - I'd be interested to hear his response [followed by link to this thread and my full name and contact details]

Alasdair Roberts: Thanks for sending the link. Somebody else already drew my attention to the thread. I haven't read it in its entirety- only the first message.

It's regrettable to have caused offence; however, I think it's healthy that the song, whether in performance or on record, should provoke thought in this individual (the first poster), thereby resulting in the ensuing discussion around this sensitive subject matter.

Best wishes,

Alasdair


Me:
I am the originator of the thread (pretty obvious as my full name is there, I don't hide behind nicknames etc).

I walked out of your performance and was upset for hours and to some extent it was on my mind for days.

Glad you think that's healthy.

Paul

Alasdair Roberts:
Hello Paul,

I am sorry to have caused you any upset.

Perhaps I should have phrased it differently. Despite the obvious upset, I find it encouraging that the situation has provoked some discussion around matters arising from your reaction to the performance.

All the best, and perhaps I'll see you at a gig in Cardiff or nearby some day.

Alasdair