Apropos of the assertion that drawing parallels between Nazi actions and actions of Israelis, must be seen as anti-semitic:

"The judges likened his stated willingness "to murder even women and children in cold blood" to "Hitler's methods in France".

The judges in question being Israeli judges, in a trial of a group of Israeli soldiers, which was kept secret for 54 years.(Israel learns of a hidden shame in its early years")

That goes to suggest that MtheGM's strictures on Jim were excessive. As for Jim Carroll's bullheaded campaign against Keith for his interpretation of a post Keith once made, that's equally over the top.

Go and play some music...