In both cases, you think the captain might regret having left the pier? Costa's reputation, none to good before, is in the can.

On the earlier subject:

Typical Admiralty court hearing:

Captain, how close to shore were you?
Mumble
And were you on deck?
Mumble
Were you keeping a good lookout, as required by maritime law and custom?
Mumble
Then, why did you not see the rock and take the necessary action to avoid collision?