Hey, that's good news about the Voice Squad! I love their singing and was lucky enough to hear them live and close up once or twice.

For what it's worth (Ebor Fiddler above) I have a copy of the 1905 English Hymnal and, like you, expected this hymn to be there, for the reasons you state. But it's not - unless it's under a completely different set of words - there is no tune index in my version. It is, however, in my mother's 1939 copy of the Scottish Hymnary (published 1928).

Marje