The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #145992 Message #3380414
Posted By: GUEST,chris
23-Jul-12 - 11:31 AM
Thread Name: Tech: Concertina button design
Subject: RE: Tech: Concertina button design
" which likely is the oldest argument of all against progress...
Is it progress or is it just 'different'? Does being different make it better?
I would be interested to know how many players have done as you advocate - modify a £2000+ concertina with no certainty of an improvement.
I suggest that you get a maker to make a concertina to your 'design' and see how many it sells - this would be the ultimate test of your theories.
Bear in mind that what suits you, ergonomically, may not suit the next man or woman - their hands may be of different size to yours.
A 'standard' format may not be a total answer and a number of players will fall outside the format (and they may have to work a bit harder) - but an awful lot will fit into the 'standard' and be quite happy with Wheatstone's original layout
This is an issue that you have to take into account.
chris