The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #94304   Message #3381353
Posted By: GUEST,B
25-Jul-12 - 12:45 PM
Thread Name: Stan Hugill - the real words?
Subject: RE: Stan Hugill - the real words?
Stan's book does have all the shanties in clean versions and I am sure that there are things that were left to the imagination. What is the true meaning of a "Hog's eye". W.B. Whall's collection of shanties has any "questionable" verses left out, leaving many of the working shanties too short to be really singable. His defence of this was that:
"Shanties and work-songs sung at sea are of the vilest filth!"
Instead of Political Correctness, can we have some historical accuracy please?