The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #15280   Message #3480379
Posted By: McGrath of Harlow
16-Feb-13 - 11:37 AM
Thread Name: Origins: Rose of Tralee - anything to add ...?
Subject: RE: Origins: Rose of Tralee - anything to add ...?
Lonesome - the Oxford Dictionary gives it's earliest appearance in print as 1647, and in Victorian times there's a citing from Dickens. Of course that in itself doesn't mean the verse isn't likely enough more recent, but sometimes we are too quick on the trigger about supposed anachronisms.

I incline towards the view that what matters in a song isn't whether it sticks to the original words or not, but how it works as a song. And I think the India verse especially does work well.

"Print the legend"