Speaking as a non-believer, I see the logic of not painting every Catholic or Jew or Muslim with the same brush. Conscience is a personal thing and everybody has a difference sense of it.

For example, in the Catholic practice, I see the value of Liberation Theology.

I see that Jews are on board with BDS in their criticism of Israel.

Certainly there are Muslims who don't accept the violent interpretation given by other Muslims of Jihad.

Ghandi, a Hindu preached an equal status of Hindu and Moslem alike.

I think if Catholicism is to survive, the followers will have to rebel against the unjust Church edicts. I think this may be true for other religions as well.