I quoted the first "Guest: Concerned" post n this thread to illustrate that she has not made a good first impression on me. The bit about "Marxism" was I thought, incidental to my purpose.

But taken on its own, I think that Marxism or at least Stalinism as it has been practiced belongs in a conversation about definitions of atheism. I think she was quite clever and thoughtful to slip that it.

Seems like she is in accord with you in this statement Jim.

"Why dont you all get to grips with the fact that all this religan is a smoke screen put about by people who want to dominate you, and make you forget about the real issues."

Here debates style comes across as Shaw's attitude with pete's grammar. Entertaining, to say the least.