The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #150413   Message #3504495
Posted By: Desert Dancer
16-Apr-13 - 07:00 PM
Thread Name: BS: pie crimpers or pastry cutters?
Subject: BS: pie crimpers or pastry cutters?
The Edible Geography blog has an entry featuring scrimshaw pastry tools on exhibit at the New Bedford Whaling Museum. She calls these "pie crimpers" and theorizes on the diversity:
"The exhibit attributes this functional extravagance to many hours of boredom at sea, but also to the American diet in the nineteenth century. A typical New England meal of the era would involve not just pie, but pies, in both savoury and sweet form. Armed with a crimping multi-tool, a lucky whaler's spouse or mother need never fear a moment's confusion differentiating between her cherry and chicken pies."

If I google on "pie (or pastry) crimper" some of these and their modern versions come up. But, I think that these are (mostly) better labelled as "pastry cutters". In the pie/pastry context, I defined "crimp" as pressing together layers of dough to seal them together, usually with some decorative flourish.

If you want to make a lattice-top pie, you can use these cutting wheels like a pizza cutter to make the strips of dough -- with pretty zig-zag edges. Here is an edge-on view that shows the cutting edge more clearly.

You can also make fancy edges on cookies/biscuits like this, or cut apart filled dough (e.g. ravioli) like this. (You seal the layers together by wetting and pressing, though. The tool just cuts.)

In all the how-tos that I've seen (in books or online), I've never seen one of these wheeled tools used for pressing layers of dough together to seal them.

In the Google search, I do find this and this type of wheeled-tool, which does fit my idea of a tool that can be used to press together layers of dough to seal the edged of a closed pie, or decorate the edge of a single-crust pie. Here's a lovely and detailed Victorian ad: the crimping wheel also cuts (with a straight edge) simultaneously -- but the little zig-zag cutting wheel is used for some other purpose.

Another type of result for "pastry crimping tool" is a pair of small, toothed tongs that can be used to pinch dough together for a decorative effect. Also these and these.

I do see crimping as a function of the non-wheel portion of this scrimshaw and this brass and this multi-tool: used to pinch dough against fingers or a pan, they would do the trick in a decorative way.

The definition of "crimp" is "compress (something) into small folds or ridges" (Oxford American English). Are people expanding that definition to any zig-zag, even if it's cut, rather than compressed?

Or is it just that there are a lot of people who have never actually used these tools making labels for them? :-)

~ Becky in Long Beach
(is it obvious that I have time on my hands at the moment? The scrimshaw is lovely.)