"Maybe on par with those who criticise Islamist atrocities as Islamophobes, eh Jim? "
You and your little band of brothers have chosen to do that - I would revisit your rant if I were you.
Making the murder a religious issue is to smear everybody who follows that religion with that murder, and to then attempt to show that that religion provides the incentive for such acts confirms that this is your claim.
Your buddy took it a step further by claiming that degeneracy was "implanted" in "all male Muslim Pakistanis" - can't say clearer than that.
Jim Carroll