The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #152354 Message #3566920
Posted By: Lighter
14-Oct-13 - 07:57 PM
Thread Name: Traditional Music: Where are we going wrong?
Subject: RE: Traditional Music: Where are we going wrong?
> 'Shoals of Herring' has a Roud number, as does Jimmy Rodgers' 'Away Out on the Mountain'
A fragment of "Shoals of Herring," at least, was collected (naively) by H. P. Beck as a traditional song from an Irish singer who, apparently, hadn't learned it from a record. Beck wasn't infallible, and neither was his fisherman singer who knew only part of the song.
Nor has anyone suggested that Steve Roud is infallible.
Even if he *has* done some of the most important work in folk/trad scholarship of the past 50 years.