Thanks for your good wishes for today Musket.
I hope your biopsies bring no nasty surprises.

I am challenging this.
His earlier work was highly critical of the commanders and purpose.   Yet in Catastrophe he does an about face.   Why

He is quite clear that mistakes were indeed made and is not uncritical of the leadership now, but he has made no "about face"

If he has, please prove me wrong with an extract or quote.