The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #151894   Message #3588050
Posted By: Steve Gardham
01-Jan-14 - 05:34 AM
Thread Name: DTStudy: Well Sold the Cow/Crafty Farmer-Child 283
Subject: RE: DTStudy: Well Sold the Cow/Crafty Farmer-Child 283
Okay, this is only my own opinion, but it's also how the Roud Index works.
The 3 separate ballads are
The farmer himself is the hero
The farmer's daughter is the hero
Yorkshire John is the hero

There should be 3 Roud numbers but I'll check this. Off the top of my head they have no text in common other than the odd word that you would expect in songs dealing with the same story. In my book that makes them separate songs. If you really need it I'll check out their differences and post.