The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #153685   Message #3601008
Posted By: Will Fly
13-Feb-14 - 03:05 AM
Thread Name: Chord Req: Why Requests for chords?
Subject: RE: Chord Req: Why Requests for chords?
If the person making the request is actually seeking to copy the sequence used by a particular performer, is that because they are copying the whole performance? If so, maybe they should think again. Why reproduce what someone else already does (or did at some past time)?

I take it you're talking in the context of solo performance, Richard? Any attempt to play with just one other person - say at a singaround or session - will require some degree of harmonic commonality. Only last Sunday I was gently told off for playing a D chord at one point in the song "Spanish Ladies" - apparently it should have been a C. My ear told me otherwise, but I deferred to the person who started up his version of the song.

Horses for courses - an don't mention jazz, where you must know the right basic sequences for a start before you can go off on chordal and melodic sprees...