"I never claimed anything like that."
Will you stop ******* lying - this is exactly what you said and this is my only response to you %80 clam - I have never disputed the figure, nor do I
If you haven't got the intelligence not to lie about things that are easily retrievable, - at least have the decency to put your hands up to it when you are exposed as the lying little toad that you are.
Not only are you continuing to lie about what I have said, your posting shows you as a liar about claiming that you have only commented on three items.
You lied then and you are lying now.
I made a mistake about the executions, acknowledged that mistake and aplogiesd - it is highly understandable that you failed to recognise the apology - you appear to be unable to tell the difference between them and "snivelling", as you have described it.
The wrong powrred shells were sent - I acvknowledged that as soon as it was pointed out, and I also added that it didn't make the slightest difference to those who were slaughtered and humiliated at mMons because they had been sent the WRONG AMMUNITION
Kitchener resigned and withdrew his resignation - it's all in the book should you ever get round to reading one.
Only a slimy little weasel like you and Trooper Tommy would attempt to make some sort of capital out of slips - especially when they have been acknowledged
By the way - you have shown no sign whatever of having watched yhe programmes, any more than you have of having read a book - as for "a life-long study - please do not repeat that while I'm drinking coffee - Pat has never got the hang of the Heimlich Manoeuver
Carry on lying - diiis-miiiss
Jim Carroll
I am curious to see how you will attempt to explain this away, you don't go in for "snivelling" do you?

Subject: RE: BS: Armistice Day (debate)
From: Keith A of Hertford - PM
Date: 14 Nov 13 - 03:07 PM
Diaries were forbidden but soldiers kept them anyway.
The Imperial War museum has thousands.
Rob Naylor said he has one kept by his Grandad, so that was a silly thing to say Jim.

Letters were censored for locations and activities.
If a soldier was nervous of expressing disillusionment, he would just wait until he got leave.
He would not need to lie in his letters. Just not mention it.

Over 80% of soldiers made it home, so we can be sure what they thought.

So you are talking bollocks again.
All the historians are not fools who need you to explain their job to them.
Subject: RE: BS: Armistice Day (debate)


From: Jim Carroll - PM
Date: 15 Nov 13 - 05:08 AM

Where - what are their findings?
Sources and links only accepted - not bullshit jingoistic claims by you
You have made claims on the basis of these diaries - where did you get your information - sorry a rhetorical question - you made them up as you make all your 'information" up.
"Over 80% of soldiers made it home, so we can be sure what they thought"
What did they think?
Stop lying
Jim Carroll