Yes Keith, I was talking about new cases because Akenaton was.

4.7 % is a long way from a majority. 10 times 4.7% is not a majority.

Akenaton, My mathematics is just fine. 1 in 12, your worst case, is not a majority, You cannot generalize 1 in 12 to all. That is stereotyping.

Yes there IS cause for concern, 6,300 people getting HIV is 6,300 too many IMHO. But there is no cause for opposing same-sex marriage and testing all gay men in the figures you provide.

Please, find better data or find another topic.