"B, what evolutionists think they know has already been contradicted by experimental, testable, repeatable science, but the alternative of " allowing a divine foot in the door " is clearly unpalatable to atheists."

Even if your so called "Creation Scientists" (an oxymoron) could disprove the theory of evolution with genuine peer reviewed evidence, THAT WOULD NOT AMOUNT TO THE SLIGHTEST EVIDENCE FOR YOUR PREFERRED ALTERNATIVE!

There is NO connection which even suggests that these two points of view amount to an "either, or" alternative.

You start with a conclusion and work backwards to non existent evidence of the unknowable and untestable.