If you are purely judging this institution then the police report will be a source of evidence (not judgement.) However, the overall fitness for purpose of church run social care already has legal judgements against it and has been found wanting.

Interestingly, with little chance of finding anyone still around who made decisions there, it will never have full legal closure, so the stain will remain. All the more important that the Catholic Church demonstrate how they will in future prevent such things happening in their name.

If they can't, how can they therefore take credit for some of the good things carried out in their name?   The days of religious organisations having it both ways are over in civilised society. Too many cracks for the wallpaper to cover.