The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #154754   Message #3635525
Posted By: Doug Chadwick
22-Jun-14 - 05:49 AM
Thread Name: The shame in singing covers
Subject: RE: The shame in singing covers
... If you can't write your own material don't pretend to be a musician.

Taking it to the extreme, where would that leave song-writing duos?
                Music by ………….. Lyrics by …………..
If they were performing individually, would one of them get stuck playing instrumentals and the other have to read out the words as a poem? Even worse, if the lyrics were the result of collaboration, would the singer have to leave gaps when he got to the other person's lines?



I do agree, though, that hearing someone rip off somebody else's act is less than satisfying. In the area where I live, all we ever get is tribute bands. We don't even have a proper venue to bring quality acts to – just an auditorium which is supposed to double up as a sports hall. The trouble is that people who have been born and brought up here, have known no better and seem to find it perfectly acceptable.

... How else would we get to see the Beatles or Buddy Holly live? ...

We are not getting to see them live. We are getting to see a tribute act. No matter how good they are, don't fool yourself that you are seeing anything else. If you want to hear the original, then buy the record.

DC