I found Lizzie's first summary of contrary evidence in the closed thread interesting.
She stated her belief passionately and clearly. She did not deserve the vituperation that followed.
Will there be an appeal in the case?

This thread also is becoming childish.

SRS, those he said/didn't say arguments are infesting all threads that attempt serious content.
I would let the threads continue, but censor out all the stupid comment.

Of course, one, I am the best judge of what is worthy, and two, my time is too valuable to spend it on childish argument.

Seriously, SRS, I sympathise with you.

I just wish some of the repetitive yes/no contingent would fall of the edge of the world.