The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #155997   Message #3676008
Posted By: Marje
09-Nov-14 - 03:59 PM
Thread Name: No man's land protest
Subject: RE: No man's land protest
To return to the topic of the song, I've now had a listen to part of the Joss Stone version. I couldn't stand more than a verse or so of it , so I never got as far as the bowdlerised bit. It's a truly dreadful rendition - over-orchestrated, cheesy, messy - and why did anyone think it was a good idea to choose a singer who favours a fake-American, "soul" style of vocals? Utterly inappropriate, and the result is simply a horrible noise, with neither the tune nor the lyrics easy to discern.

Yesterday's Independent carried a report about this controversy, and quoted Bogle's reservations about this version of his song.

Marje