I'm reading with great interest! Definitely did not post for the fun of stirring things up and did not think it was a stupid question (Bonzo3legs, how charming you are). I'm really pleased that most people are saying great stuff about singing for the hell of singing. In the places I sing, I've often wondered if being whatever 'authentic' means is more important than being there at all but it doesn't seem to be the case for you lot. Good on you!

LD

PS: Achmelvich I think your comment about rich people not being as good at creating art and being better at buying and selling is fascinating. I don't agree, but it's made me think interesting thoughts so thanks!