The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #156361   Message #3687242
Posted By: Lighter
19-Dec-14 - 06:42 PM
Thread Name: Origins: Fair Margaret & Sweet Willliam- Child 74
Subject: RE: Origins: Fair Margaret & Sweet Willliam- Child 74
> so why did Robert Chambers; John Chappell (Roxburghe), John Ashton and Frank Sidgwick all have "take."

Roxburghe prefers "take" but allows "talk" as an alternative reading.

Conceivably Percy altered "take" to "talk" to make the situation rather less erotic. No way to know. Oral tradition could have changed either to the other, and more than once.

Presumably the Roxburghe text is the most earliest and most authoritative.