The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #145932   Message #3705484
Posted By: GUEST
30-Apr-15 - 11:32 AM
Thread Name: Review: Grumpy British Folkies part 273
Subject: RE: Review: Grumpy British Folkies part 273
folk songs evolve and are not made

No. Folk songs are first MADE and then they evolve, or maybe they don't. Maybe even in their natural habitat they remain unchanged - like George Bruce Thompson's McGinty's Meal an' Ale - which he wrote shortly before it was quickly snapped up by singers (Davie Stewart) and academics (Grieg & Duncan) alike. It remains unchanged to this day - but a highly evolved class of a Traditional Song even so. Then there's the songs of Tommy Armstrong, and other amazing things like The Keilder Hunt, The Shepherd's Song and Til the Kye Comes Hame - each sung by one of the finest Traditional Singers (Willie Scott), each with a known author (one may even have been written by him), each of them unchanged, and yet each totally and undoubtedly a bona fide Traditional Folk Song. I'm sure they might even have Roud numbers burned into their hides by now.