The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #157516   Message #3719095
Posted By: Phil Edwards
26-Jun-15 - 12:39 PM
Thread Name: Origins: George Collins: revisited
Subject: RE: Origins: George Collins: revisited
Some versions of 'William Taylor' are also the burlesque version.

Or a bit of both? The version Tony Rose recorded seems pretty straight but for the last verse ("If young people in Wells or London"), which is out of a burlesque.

I suspect sometimes a burlesque gets taken for an original because the humour wasn't broad or obvious enough for a new audience to spot. This need not be because the burlesque writer's sense of humour was tremendously subtle; it might just be that the burlesque wasn't that good, possibly because it was dashed off as a fairly close copy of an original ballad with a few gags or bits of bathos stuck in.