The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #158024   Message #3733895
Posted By: GUEST,Grishka
29-Aug-15 - 04:47 AM
Thread Name: BS: polygamy-Bigamy laws
Subject: RE: BS: polygamy-Bigamy laws
As soon as we question traditional marriage, we must distinguish its various roles:
  1. Sharing a household - not restricted by law but posing other problems
  2. Having sex together- subjected to various legal restrictions, e.g. of incest
  3. Raising children
  4. Being accepted as a family by society
  5. Being accepted as a family by laws of taxation and inheritance
Only the latter role is political in the current discussion, whereas weltanschauung is mainly concerned with the other roles. "Gay marriage" is a misnomer by more than one criterion.

Similarly, polygamy as a sociological problem is scarcely related to its legal acceptance. "De-facto harems" are not unusual, whether supported by a cultural/religious tradition or charisma or wealth, e.g. of a film star.

Large same-sex households, each member vowing fidelity and in some cases even wearing a golden ring, are highly praised in some traditional Christian communities - by the name of religious orders.