The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #158525   Message #3752353
Posted By: Jim Carroll
20-Nov-15 - 02:03 PM
Thread Name: BS: Jingoism or Commemoration
Subject: RE: BS: Jingoism or Commemoration
"but they were not summary executions "
You've been given them and all you can do is call the soldiers who spoke of them liars.
"and most of those condemned were not actually executed."
Doesn't make any difference to those with shellshock who were =- none should have been
"Pennell said it was a "myth" that British and Irish people were "deluded, brainwashed and naïvely duped into supporting the conflict."
Out of context again - she said a great deal more - mentioning fear of humiation - and particularly that the reasons were complex fro enlisting - why do you persist in this - you have lied about reading her book - you are dealing with misleading half-quotes - again.
PARAGRAPHS ARE NOT ENOUGH - READ THE BOOK
None of these people said what you claim if you read the articles in full.You are trying to score points yet again
Does being a Christian encourage you to lie for your country? - I don't know any Christians who behaves like you - I really don't.
You are a shining advert for atheism
Jim Carroll