Once again professor you have demonstrated your complete inability to understand the written word.

The history you profess to read is just ONE picture of that period. They are not and cannot be the WHOLE picture.

Some people, that is those with any degree of intelligence, read absorb and decipher the information presented and consider ALL the available data.

We do not dismiss historians merely because we do not agree with their politics or that their books are not sold in High Street bookshops or because they wrote more than 20 years ago or they have an axe to grind. We accept that and judge their work accordingly.

To dismiss any historian is extremely foolish, but sadly we have come to expect no more of you.

Thesis, antithesis, synthesis. It's really quite simple.