The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #146595   Message #3752980
Posted By: GUEST
23-Nov-15 - 02:54 PM
Thread Name: Can a pop song become traditional?
Subject: RE: Can a pop song become traditional?
"They ARE in the public domain." - Jim Carroll.

Err.. No they aren't. Just because we might ignore PRS doesn't mean copyrighted songs are in the public domain when sung in pubs.

You might want to define folk through cheating on hard working song writers but I have more respect for the genre. I may not pay Vin Garbutt when I sing his songs but a) he knows I and others do and is comfortable with it and b) in return I buy his albums and go to his concerts when nearby (ok and have been known to put him up for the night.)

But I'm still in breach technically of copyright.

Copyright allows people to write songs without them being stolen. Many folk songs are written by people scraping a living writing songs. By Jim's reckoning one of my pop songs I wrote many years ago and a friend still performs to this day (it's crap as songs go mind) is a real folk song because I never copyrighted it.

And there was me thinking it was about the music not the status. Keep wriggling.









Genres.