Guest,
If 8 of them were shite reviews but 2 were good which would you put on your website.

I would put up the one that most accurately described the message of the book.
I would probably write it myself.

Jim claimed on the basis of one review by some right wing non historian that Hastings meant something else.
He did not.
The reviews I posted were all by other military historians and make clear that the book, like all the others written in recent decades, find that Jim's view's are just discredited myths.

I have been telling you all that for years now.
I was right.