"I suggest we leave it there unless and until you can find any support for your dogma from people who actually know about WW1."
I'm sure you do!!
The crap review was written by historian David Crane - ONE OF THE "REAL" HISTORIANS YOU PUT UP IN DEFENCE OF YOUR ARGUMENT WAY BACK IN THE EARLY DAYS
Yup - I must have lost it.
Game, set and match, I think (using your own logic for participating in these discussions)
Jim Carroll