Jim,
The crap review was written by historian David Crane - ONE OF THE "REAL" HISTORIANS YOU PUT UP IN DEFENCE OF YOUR ARGUMENT WAY BACK IN THE EARLY DAYS

That WAS a lie and a blatant one.
Google searching Mudcat proves that I never used him to defend my views.
He has never written anything on WW1.
You did lie Jim, and you should retract in the same font.

You now know that Crane had got it wrong about Hastings.
He "loves" the army because of its "achievements."

You reject current historical knowledge Jim.
Your views are not based on evidence, just political dogma.

Unless and until any of you can find any historian who still believes that shit, this discussion is stalled.
Can you Jim?