The discussion has moved on Jim.
Time to draw a line.
You have been arguing all these years that the WW1 was futile, the people somehow duped into support, and the army badly led.

On this thread I have quoted Catriona Pennel, Margaret Macmillan, Max Boot, Gary Sheffield, Dan Todman and, because you referred to them, Paxman and Hastings all quite unequivocally and unambiguously denying all your claims.
Many more on previous threads.
You have found nothing written for decades that supports you.

That is because you are wrong.